Completed projects
Metrics and Methodology
ASC’s [new] Metrics Methodology
The ASC has embarked upon a Metrics Methodology project to create transparency and consistency into the ‘metric’ standard-setting dimension of the ASC standards. The ‘Baseline’ Methodology document published in November 2020 was issued for a 62-day public consultation period in March–May 2020 (see the documents below). It is applicable to all species-specific metrics and aims to provide minimum requirements for setting and/or revising metrics within any of the ASC standards. The ASC Metrics Methodology will also be applicable to the ASC Farm Standard once the Alignment Project is completed.
The March-May 2020 Metric Methodology public consultation was also linked to that of the Shrimp Revision ; which included documents also referring to specific ‘metrics’.
ASC particularly sought stakeholder feedback on two dimensions of the ‘Baseline’ Methodology document (listed below). Furthermore, stakeholders were encouraged to provide any general feedback which they deemed fit.
i) ‘Relevant Data’…
Data from certified farms (where applicable), non-certified farms and research studies will be consulted for revision and/or setting of new metrics.
- Is there any other type of data that should be considered as relevant for this purpose or do you consider any of the mentioned types of data as irrelevant? If so, please provide an explanation as to why you think that a certain type of data should not be included in the metric setting approach
ii) Statistical Analysis
The draft ASC Metrics Methodology stated that “data will be checked for normal distribution and homogeneity of variance” although a Gauss distribution can not necessarily be expected, especially for survival rates in highly technical systems. However, homoscedasticity is assumed to determine the sample size for non-certified farms (within revision of metrics, based on data from certified farms and literature).
A revised version of the Metrics Methodology ‘Baseline’ document was published in November 2021 (see below).
For more information, contact Kathrin Steinberg, PhD, ASC Performance Data Coordinator.
[Last updated 12.11.2021]
Other documents
- ASC Metrics Methodology _ Baseline document v1.01 (November 2021)
- ASC Metrics Methodology _ Baseline document (November 2020)
Public Consultation, March 2 – May 2, 2020
RAS Module development
Recirculating Aquaculture Systems (RAS)
Certification of aquatic products from open and semi-closed systems such as sea-cages, ponds or flow-through systems was the initial focus of the ASC standards. In recent years, however, the number of recirculating aquaculture systems (RAS) has significantly increased. Therefore ASC has developed a RAS module to adapt the ASC standards to ensure that the main impacts from RAS operations are assessed.
Contact person: Kathrin Steinberg, PhD, Head of Research, Standards and Science.
This module development is now complete. In addition to changes made following public consultation included, additional consultation with stakeholders engaged previously was undertaken to refine the definition of RAS to determine applicability of this module. Details can be reviewed here.
RAS Module – Public Consultation (Complete)
The ASC sought feedback on the proposed RAS Module, with a focus on its auditability and applicability. Suggestions for any additional considerations which should be included in RAS assessments were also welcomed.
An additional targeted consultation on the scope of the RAS Module was held in November 2021. The summary can be found here.
Further information
- Watch the webinar, narrated by Kathrin Steinberg (Head of Research, Standards and Science) who leads the RAS Module project:
[Last updated 22.04.2022]
Public Consultation, August 3 – September 4, 2020
Summary – RAS Module – August 2020 Public Consultation
Other documents linked to Public Consultation
RAS Module – Public Consultation Comments
Review – Shrimp
Public Consultation I
Consultation period: 2 March – 2 May 2020 (extended to 18 May 2020)
Status: Closed
Freshwater Crustacean Spp – Metric Revision – Consultation Summary
Freshwater Crustacean Spp Metric Revision Metric Analysis
Freshwater Spp – Environmental Indicators – Consultation Summary
Freshwater Crustacean Species – Proposed Additional Indicators
Saltwater Shrimp Spp – Metric Revision – Consultation Summary
Data Overview_Saltwater Shrimp Revision
Data Overview_Saltwater Shrimp Species_New Spp Rationale
Gap Analysis – New crustacean Spp considered for inclusion in ASC Shrimp Standard
TOR Consultation
Consultation period: 9 November – 9 December 2018
Status: Closed
Terms of Reference_Shrimp Standard v1.0 review_DRAFT
Terms of Reference_Shrimp Standard v1.0 review_DRAFT-Annex 1
Feedback Submission Form_ToR Public Consultation
Other documents
Terms of Reference (Amendment) – ASC Shrimp Standard v1.1 Review
Stakeholder Feedback received during Spring 2020 Shrimp Review Public Consultation
ASC Shrimp Standard – Revision of current metrics – Post Public Consultation (Sept. 2020) document
Review – Freshwater Trout
Public Consultation I
Initial draft – ASC Freshwater Trout Standard_v1.1Feedback Form
ToR Consultation
Consultation period: April. 24 – May 24, 2017
Status: Closed
Terms of reference – Freshwater Trout v1.0
Governance
Review – Pangasius
Public Consultation III
Public Consultation II
Consultation period: Dec. 6 2016 – Feb. 21, 2017
Status: Closed
ASC Pangasius Standard_Operational Review
Public Consultation I
Consultation period: Nov. 5 – Dec. 20, 2015
Status: Closed
Operational Review (three papers) – Stakeholder Submissions
Public consultation ToR
Consultation period: March 16 – April 15, 2015
Status: Closed
Review – Salmon – Smolt
Public Consultation I
Consultation period: Aug. 21 – Oct. 21, 2017
- Status: Closed
- ASC Salmon Section 8 – operational review
Received feedback
Feedback – Public consultation I
Feedback Fisheries Management Scotland – Public consultation I
-
ToR Consultation
Consultation period: April 16 – May 16, 2015
- Status: Closed
- Terms of Reference v1.0
- Received feedback
- Feedback ToR – operational review
- Feedback Salmon – Operational Review
Governance Documents
Review – Salmon – PTI
Public Consultation II
ASC Salmon Criterion 5 & Appendices – Operational Review
ASC Salmon PTI Consultation Paper – Operational Review
Received feedback
Feedback – Public Consultation II
Feedback – SeaChoice – Public Consultation II
Public Consultation I
ToR Consultation
Consultation period: March 16 – April 16, 2015
Status: Closed
Feedback Salmon – Operational Review